| topic: | Political violence |
|---|---|
| tags: | #zionism, #racism, #discrimination, #demonisation |
| located: | United Kingdom |
| by: | Marlene Schönberger |
The Green Party of England and Wales (GPEW) has voted to treat Zionism as a form of racism and now calls for a single Palestinian state throughout historic Palestine. Adopted at its party conference in Brighton in early October by 1,022 votes to 813, the decision revives an equation with a deeply troubling history.
UN General Assembly Resolution 3379 of 1975 called, in its title, for the ‘Elimination of all forms of racial discrimination’. Yet the text declared that the General Assembly considered ‘Zionism [to be] a form of racism and racial discrimination’. After regimes hostile to Israel had been trying to demonise Zionism since the 1960s, this resolution sought to stigmatise the very intellectual foundation of the Jewish state’s establishment as anti-emancipatory and utterly reprehensible. Only 16 years later, the UN came to its senses: the resolution was revoked in 1991, and in 1998 UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan described it as a ‘low point’.
It is morally and ethically indefensible for a Green party to revive this equation more than 50 years later. Embracing such a trivialisation of racism and demonisation of Zionism is an indicator of the dangers that a turn towards ‘left-wing populism’ implies. It reflects an attempt to offer supposedly simple solutions to complex political problems. The GPEW portrays Israel as the sole warmonger and its very existence as a colonial project. The solution therefore follows: the destruction of the world’s only Jewish state.
Zionism is a Jewish emancipation movement. It emerged in response to European antisemitism. The term describes the aspiration of Jews to have a state of their own, where they can live freely, exercise self-determination and defend themselves. The fact that antisemitism continues to rage even after the Shoah demonstrates the legitimacy of this aspiration. Many early Zionists envisaged this state in what was then Mandatory Palestine – a region with millennia-old ties to Jewish history and culture, regarded as the historical homeland of the Jewish people.
Not everyone who came to Israel was a committed Zionist. Between the early 1930s and the early 1950s, approximately 600,000 Jews immigrated from Europe to British Mandatory Palestine and later Israel. Many were refugees fleeing Nazi persecution and surviving the Shoah.
Following Israel’s establishment, they were joined by Jews from Arab countries. Some 850,000 to 900,000 Jews were forced to flee, expelled or otherwise compelled to leave their ancestral homelands amid persecution, violence and discrimination. This exodus followed the 1947–1949 conflict, known in Israel as the War of Independence and by Palestinians as the Nakba, during which some 700,000 Palestinians fled or were expelled. The war escalated into a regional conflict when armies from all neighbouring Arab states attacked following Israel’s declaration of independence.
Later, Jews from the Soviet Union followed, particularly those who managed to overcome severe emigration restrictions in the 1970s and 1980s, before a much larger wave arrived around the collapse of the Soviet Union.
The Zionist movement has never been homogeneous. Figures such as National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich certainly represent extreme right-wing and racist currents. Yet it is ridiculous to reduce Zionism to their radical fringe parties, which have become kingmakers for Benjamin Netanyahu. On top of that biased perception, left-wing Zionism, cultural Zionism and post-Zionism are just some of the strands that are often ignored. Socialist and social-democratic Zionism played a central role in the movement before Israel’s establishment in 1948 and shaped the state’s early decades. And it was left-wing Zionists and members of the Israeli peace movement who were particularly affected by the violence of 7 October 2023. They lived in the kibbutzim surrounding the Gaza Strip and sought to build a shared everyday life with Palestinians from Gaza. Some residents of the coastal enclave worked in those very kibbutzim. These facts alone should prompt reflection.
Yet particularly since the massacres and systematic sexual violence perpetrated by the Palestinian terrorist organisation Hamas, we have witnessed ‘Zionism’ being turned into a political weapon. The Jewish national movement has been declared a threat and equated with colonialism or racism. This has now gone so far that young people on the left – particularly on social media – routinely use the slur ‘Zio’, popularised by the American neo-Nazi David Duke, a former Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan.
A political left that actively challenges antisemitism has, particularly since 7 October, proved to be the exception in many places. Numerous left-wing movements appear to have recognised that antisemitism directed at Israel can mobilise voters. This may also help explain the GPEW resolution, through which the party has abandoned its role as an honest broker for a peaceful resolution of the Arab–Israeli conflict and clearly departed from the principles of the European Green Party (EGP). Within the EGP, we support the two-state solution and advocate peaceful coexistence in Israel and Palestine. We are convinced that this alone can provide the foundation for lasting peace. There is no contradiction between supporting Israeli security and Palestinian statehood. Those who claim otherwise are primarily those who deny the other side’s right to exist.
As Greens, we oppose all one-sidedness: we recognise the trauma caused by 7 October, and we recognise the horrors brought about by the war in Gaza. All of this motivates us to fight for just solutions – instead of joining in a demonisation of Israel that fuels violence against Jews.
